Strict Standards: Only variables should be assigned by reference in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/plugins/exclude-pages/exclude_pages.php on line 92
Strict Standards: Only variables should be assigned by reference in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/plugins/exclude-pages/exclude_pages.php on line 92
Strict Standards: Only variables should be assigned by reference in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/plugins/exclude-pages/exclude_pages.php on line 92
Strict Standards: Only variables should be assigned by reference in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/plugins/exclude-pages/exclude_pages.php on line 92
Strict Standards: Only variables should be assigned by reference in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/plugins/exclude-pages/exclude_pages.php on line 92
Strict Standards: Only variables should be assigned by reference in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/plugins/exclude-pages/exclude_pages.php on line 92
Strict Standards: Only variables should be assigned by reference in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/plugins/exclude-pages/exclude_pages.php on line 92
Strict Standards: Only variables should be assigned by reference in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/plugins/exclude-pages/exclude_pages.php on line 92
Strict Standards: Only variables should be assigned by reference in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/plugins/exclude-pages/exclude_pages.php on line 92
RSS Feed
After the publication of the annual Gettysburg issue of Blue and Gray magazine two issues ago, J. D. Petruzzi and I felt an overwhelming need to respond. The featured article was by a licensed battlefield guide named Andrea Custer that spells out a new interpretation of Farnsworth’s Charge on the afternoon of July 3, 1863. That article relies on misrepresentations and twistings of facts to suit the theory, and we came to the conclusion that it was written to intentionally mislead the public to promote the author’s own agenda.
Consequently, we composed a 5500 word rebuttal of the theory that was based entirely on the facts. We knew it was long, and we knew that we ran the risk of it being too long to run in the magazine as a letter to the editor.
Today, I got news about it. There’s good news, bad news, and then more good news.
The good news: We will have a 500-1000 word letter to the editor on the subject in the next issue of the magazine.
The bad news: Regular reader Scott Patchan’s feature article for the issue is VERY long at 18,400 words, and there is no room to run our entire piece. This year, at least, the piece will not be run as we wrote it.
The good news: Dave Roth, the publisher of the magazine is going to make it up to us by permitting us to publish the entire piece, complete with maps, illustrations, and a General’s Tour of the conventional interpretation of Farnsworth’s Charge in next year’s Gettysburg issue. So, for those who haven’t read what we cobbled together, sadly, you will have to wait. My concern, of course, is that by the time it does run, nobody will remember or care, but given the nature of Gettysburg controversies, this one keeps coming back up and keeps getting argued. We shall see, but I am pretty sure that it will stir up the waters once again.
To give just a taste to tease and tantalize you: we present lots of evidence from the veterans–those who were actually there–to demonstrate that these events took place where the conventional interpretation places them, that some of the sources relied upon in the alterantive theory have been misstated and/or misrepresented, and that the actual events played out just how conventional interpretations have depicted them.
Sorry you will have to wait, but at least it will be run in full.
Scridb filterComments
Comments are closed.
Sponsors
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: id in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Notice: Undefined index: std in /home/netscrib/public_html/civilwarcavalry/wp-content/themes/wittenberg/footer.php on line 8
Back to top
Blogs I like 
- Andrew Duppstadt
- Andy Etman
- Blue Gray Daily
- Bob O'Neill
- Bottle Rocket Science
- Brooks Simpson
- Bruce Long
- Charlie Knight
- Civil Warriors
- Corey Meyer
- Craig Swain
- Damien Shiels
- Dave Powell
- David Woodbury
- Dimitri Rotov
- Drew Wagenhoffer
- Emerging Civil War Historians
- Harry Smeltzer
- J. D. Petruzzi
- Jack Dempsey
- Jim Miller
- Jim Rosebrock
- Jim Schmidt
- John Hoptak
- Kevin Levin
- Kraig McNutt
- Lee Hutch
- Mannie Gentile
- Mark Grimsley
- Matt Lively
- Michael Aubrecht
- Michael C. Hardy
- Michael Lynch
- Mike Block
- Mike Noirot
- Mysteries and Conundrums
- Rea Andrew Redd
- Richard J. Bell
- Richard McCormick
- Robert H. Moore, II
- Robert Redd
- Scott Mingus
- Scott Patchan
- Sean Heuvel
- Steve Light
- Susan Wittenberg
- Ted Savas
- TOCWOC
- Tom Clemens
- You Stink! blog
- Civil War Sites
- Central Ohio Civil War Roundtable
- Civil War Trust
- CWDG Online
- Dennis Morris
- J. David Petruzzi
- Ohio Civil War 150
- Ohio in the Civil War
- One Continuous Fight: The Retreat from Gettysburg and the Pursuit of Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia, July 4-14, 1863
- Pennsylvania in the Civil War
- Plenty of Blame to Go Around: Jeb Stuart’s Controversial Ride to Gettysburg
- Randy Drais
- Rush’s Lancers, also known as the Sixth Pennsylvania Cavalry
- The Books of Eric J. Wittenberg
- Wade Sokolosky
- West Virginia in the Civil War
- Woodbury Historical Tours
- Compilation Blogs
- Other Sites
- Our sponsors
- Publishers of Civil War History
- Popular Pages
- Archives
Did Dave Roth explain his rationale for printing the Farnsworth article by Andrea Custer?
Ian,
No.
Eric
Well, it stinks to have to wait a year, but my granny always said, good things come to those that wait…fwiw
Dave told Eric that our submission convinced him that Custer is wrong, and the conventional interpretation is correct. I’m just about done finishing the 1000-word version of our letter, so at least folks will be able to read that shortly.
This wasn’t the way we originally hoped all this would play out, but as Eric said I think the issue that will be devoted to it next year will be worth it. And hopefully it will set the record straight once and for all, and any hare-brainness about Farnsworth will end 🙂
J.D. Petruzzi