03 October 2011 by Published in: Battlefield preservation 8 comments

This past weekend was one of my favorite events, the annual Middleburg Conference on the Art of Command in the Civil War, hosted by the Mosby Heritage Area Association. This was the 14th annual conference, and my fourth as a presenter. More than 90 attended, meaning that this year’s conference was the largest yet for the MHAA, which is a tribute to Childs Burden (the man who is responsible for the conference and the president of the MHAA) and the rest of his officers and board, all of whom do a great job. All proceeds benefit the good work interpreting the area being done by the MHAA.

This year’s program was titled “Cavalry to the Field!” and dealt with mounted operations in the Eastern Theater. The best thing about it was the gathering of the cavalry guys, as I like to call our merry little band of brothers. It’s been something like 14 years since we were all together at a conference last, and I really enjoyed having the opportunity to get caught up with all of them. On the program were old friends Bud Hall, Horace Mewborn, Bob O’Neill, Marshall Krolick, Bruce Venter, and Bob Trout. A number of the attendees, including Jim Morgan, Jim Nolan, and a handful of others, are also old friends, and it was also great to see them. Also on the program was J.E.B. Stuart, IV, who gave a really interesting talk on his great-grandfather’s service in the west during his years in the Regular Army before the Civil War.

I did a talk based on our book Plenty of Blame to Go Around: Jeb Stuart’s Controversial Ride to Gettysburg. I’ve done that talk dozens of times, but this was the first time that I’ve ever given it with someone actually named Jeb Stuart in the room, and let me tell you, it was a little intimidating to do so. Luckily, I had chatted with Colonel Stuart, who is not only a former Regular Army officer, but also a true gentleman, and knew that he didn’t disagree with my interpretation of those events. Nevertheless, it was intimidating.

This photo is of the panel discussion at the end of the day on Saturday. Bud Hall is beside me, and because I was leaning forward to answer a question, he can’t be seen there. From left to right: Horace Mewborn, Bob Trout, Marshall Krolick, Jeb Stuart, IV, Bob O’Neill, me, Bud Hall (although you can’t see him next to me), Bruce Venter, and the fellow at the lectern is Childs Burden. If you want to see this photo (or the other two) in a larger version, just click on the photo.

Sunday featured a full-day tour of the Brandy Station battlefield. Naturally, Bud Hall led the tour, but a number of us helped. I had responsibility for one of the buses, and Mike Block, a former member of the board of trustees of the Brandy Station Foundation, was with me. Mike and I have led several tours of the battlefield previously, and we work well together. Bruce Venter, who is the world’s only known fan of Judson Kilpatrick, also pitched in when we visited Rose Hill, the Stevensburg house that served as Kilpatrick’s headquarters during the winter encampment of the Army of the Potomac in 1863-1864. There were about 75 people on the tour, and we needed an extra bus to accommodate the entire crowd.

Bud asked me to discuss the 6th Pennsylvania Cavalry’s heroic charge into the teeth of the Confederate horse artillery on the St. James Church plateau during the morning phase of the fighting on the Beverly Ford road. That’s me describing the action at St. James Church.

This was my first visit to the Brandy Station battlefield since May, when Lake Troilo was at its worst. I knew that some efforts have been undertaken to begin to try to correct the terrible harm done to the battlefield by Tony Troilo, but I hadn’t seen the state of things again until yesterday. The good news is that the dams of Flat Run have been removed and that the pond seems to have pretty well drained. However, the draining of the pond doesn’t restore the earth that was turned in order to build the dams and dig the pond, nor can it ever. While Troilo is under orders to restore things, we will never know how many artifacts and final resting places of dead soldiers were disturbed by this process.

The final stop of the tour was on a parcel of land owned by the Brandy Station Foundation and which overlooks Lake Troilo and the southern face of Fleetwood Hill. While we were there, Bud told the whole sordid tale of the construction of Lake Troilo and the complete and utter abandonment of its duty to protect the battlefield by the president and board of directors of the Brandy Station Foundation. The attendees–many of whom are well-heeled major donors to battlefield preservation efforts–were as horrified to learn of the betrayal by the BSF of its duty to protect the battlefield as we were when it first happened.

At the end of the day, it seems like the only people who think that the BSF’s non-handling of this situation is appropriate and acceptable are the ones who betrayed the trust reposed in them to serve as stewards of the battlefield. That speaks volumes. However, the ones responsible not only refuse to do the right thing by resigning, they refuse to acknowledge that they were wrong about this situation. I guess the next time a developer comes along, the BSF will welcome him or her with open if the check has enough zeroes after it, like what happened with the Gettysburg Battlefield Preservation Association and the casino promoters.

Nevertheless, the conference was an overwhelming success, and I was honored to have played a small role in it. I look forward to being invited again soon. And for those who have never attended this excellent program, please consider doing so, as you will not be disappointed.

Scridb filter


  1. dan
    Mon 03rd Oct 2011 at 8:38 pm

    >Bruce Venter, who is the world’s only known fan of Judson Kilpatrick

    What??? Judson Kilpatrick has a fan?? How is this possible?
    On what basis can anybody like Kilpatrick? Honest questions… somebody wanna help me out on this?

  2. D. Reves
    Mon 03rd Oct 2011 at 11:27 pm

    This was truly a great event. Each of the presentations was outstanding. Your talk on Stuart’s ride to Gettysburg clearly stimulated much thought, as demonstrated by the number of questions raised during the panel session. Thanks Again.

  3. Dennis
    Tue 04th Oct 2011 at 5:59 am


    I appreciated your comment on the Middleburg Conference though other commitments made it impossible for me to attend. However, I would love to know about similar activities, as would perhaps others here. Any chance to publicize them ahead of time, or devote a section of the blog to them?


  4. Tue 04th Oct 2011 at 7:58 am

    Thanks so much for the kind words about the talk at the conference. That’s one that I really do enjoy giving, and it always seems to be well-received.

    Dennis, I try to announce these things here. I announced this one months ago when the program was finalized. I will continue to do so.

  5. Dennis
    Wed 05th Oct 2011 at 5:51 am

    Thanks Eric. Must have been before I became a regular reader!

  6. Thu 06th Oct 2011 at 4:58 pm

    Thanks for sharing the photos, Eric. It’s been years since Ronnie and I have seen any of your group pictured here… really takes me back. Would have loved to attend this year… in fact we haven’t been to the Middleburg Conference since the year after we retired from our book business. Again thanks and …
    Best regards,
    Linda Breedlove

  7. Al Ovies
    Sat 08th Oct 2011 at 12:24 pm


    Though I am am currently working on a more “modern” project, my heart wanted to be on that battlefild with you and the “cavalry guys.”

  8. Pat C Hediger
    Wed 12th Oct 2011 at 9:02 pm

    I had a wonderful time and learned so much, as I always do. Thanks to everyone who made my little vacation a resounding success. It is almost like going to Mecca.

Comments are closed.

Copyright © Eric Wittenberg 2011, All Rights Reserved
Powered by WordPress